This is an opinion piece. The views are the author’s own.
Every Black Friday, the same red tag appears on the same shirt: “40% off.” Off what, exactly? Shoppers are rarely told, and that gap is where the trouble starts. Stores should have to show how long an item actually sold at the “original” price. Until then, treat the crossed-out number as decoration.
The “Original” Price Is Often a Story
A July investigation by InvestigateTV, syndicated by local stations, followed a Macy’s shirt marked 40% off $149. The reporter found a manufacturer’s tag listing $109. Forty percent off that would be about $65, not the $89 on the sale sign. Macy’s did not address the gap directly. It said its pricing cadence “varies” with the nature and seasonality of the merchandise.
The same story cited Consumers’ Checkbook, a nonprofit, which tracked 25 major retailers for six months starting in February 2025. Its finding, as the report describes it: at most stores, discounts were continuous. If a sale never ends, it is simply the price.
This Isn’t a Gray Area on Paper
Monica Vaca, a former deputy director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, told the outlet that inflating an “original” price before a sale, or advertising a fake list price, violates the FTC Act. The agency’s own pricing guides, in 16 CFR Part 233, address the issue. Yet Consumers’ Checkbook editor Kevin Brasler says the FTC hasn’t enforced its own rules on this in more than 40 years.
Vaca also pointed to a 2021 change: the FTC can seek an injunction in court, but it can’t get money back for consumers. A rule without refunds is a weak deterrent. State attorneys general and local prosecutors have filled some of the gap, as in a California settlement of more than $5 million with Walmart over scanner overcharges and false advertising.
What I’d Want Instead
The fix doesn’t need to be complicated. If a store advertises a percentage off, the tag should show the highest recent price and the date range it was charged. Shoppers can then judge for themselves. Honest retailers lose nothing; the ones that depend on a fiction would have to change.
Until then, here is a simple habit. Before you buy anything pricey this week, check the price history through a tracker or the store’s own past listings, then compare with another retailer. If you suspect a deceptive tag, take a photo and report it to your state attorney general or at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. It won’t fix the system, but it puts a record on file.
Our earlier piece on free-shipping minimums looks at another place where the framing does the selling. Prices should say what they mean.
More on Contoh
- Free-Shipping Minimums Make You Spend More. Stores Should Say So
- How to Shop Online Safely on Black Friday and Cyber Monday
- Hidden Fees Shouldn’t Be Legal on Delivery Apps Either